| | | | | |
| Tue | 11/04/2003 | Slam All-Stars (Exhibition) | Alumni Hall | | W, 82-73
Recap |
| Sat | 11/08/2003 | EA Sports (Exhibition) | Alumni Hall | | L, 80-74
Recap |
| Thu | 11/13/2003 | Marquette
(Coaches vs. Cancer Tournament) | Madison Square Garden | ESPN2 | L, 52-45
Recap | Box Score |  Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Mon | 11/24/2003 | Fairfield | Alumni Hall | | L, 64-59 (OT)
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Sat | 11/29/2003 | Stony Brook | Stony Brook, N.Y. | | W, 72-61
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Tue | 12/02/2003 | Hofstra | Alumni Hall | | L, 81-64
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Sat | 12/06/2003 | Duke | Durham, N.C. | ESPN | L, 79-58
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Tue | 12/09/2003 | St. Francis (N.Y.) | Alumni Hall | | W, 58-52
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Sun | 12/21/2003 | Georgia Tech | Atlanta | Fox Sports | L, 79-66
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | Gametracker | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Sun | 12/28/2003 | Penn
(MSG Holiday Festival) | Madison Square Garden | MSG | L, 63-61 (2 OT)
Recap | Stats | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Mon | 12/29/2003 | Manhattan/Holy Cross
(MSG Holiday Festival) | Madison Square Garden | MSG | W, 64-61
Recap | Box Score | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Sat | 01/03/2004 | Niagara | Madison Square Garden | MSG | W, 72-65
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Mon | 01/05/2004 | Syracuse* | MSG | FOX-NY/TWC/ESPN Radio | 7:30 PM |
| Thu | 01/08/2004 | West Virginia* | Morgantown, WV | MSG/ESPN Radio | 2:00 PM |
| Sat | 01/10/2004 | Seton Hall* | Madison Square Garden | MSG | L, 71-54
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Wed | 01/14/2004 | Miami* | Alumni Hall | FSNY | L, 70-64
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Sun | 01/18/2004 | Villanova* | Villanova, Pa. | MSG | L, 85-74
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Tue | 01/20/2004 | Georgetown* | Washington, D.C. | | L, 71-69
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Sat | 01/24/2004 | Rutgers* | Piscataway, N.J. | MSG | L, 78-70
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | Gametracker | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Wed | 01/28/2004 | West Virginia* | Alumni Hall | FSNY | L, 73-64
Recap | Box Score | Archived Audio | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Sat | 01/31/2004 | UCLA | Madison Square Garden | CBS | W, 71-55
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Wed | 02/04/2004 | Pittsburgh* | Pittsburgh, Pa. | FSNY | L, 71-51
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Sun | 02/08/2004 | Boston College* | Madison Square Garden | WWOR | L, 89-61
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Wed | 02/11/2004 | West Virginia* | Morgantown, W. Va. | | L, 86-52
Recap | Box Score | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Wed | 02/18/2004 | Georgetown* | Madison Square Garden | MSG | W, 65-58
Recap | Box Score | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Sat | 02/21/2004 | Virginia Tech* | Blacksburg, Va. | WWOR | L, 54-53
Recap | Box Score | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Tue | 02/24/2004 | Connecticut* | Madison Square Garden | ESPN2 | L, 71-53
Recap | Box Score | 1560 Radio Disney |
| Sun | 02/29/2004 | Providence* | Madison Square Garden | MSG | L, 103-78
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Wed | 03/03/2004 | Boston College* | Chestnut Hill, Mass. | Metro | L, 68-54
Recap | Box Score | Gametracker | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Sat | 03/06/2004 | Notre Dame* | Madison Square Garden | CBS | L, 89-62
Recap | Box Score | 1050 ESPN Radio |
| Wed | 03/10/2004 | BIG EAST Tournament | Madison Square Garden | ESPN/ESPN2 | TBA |
| Thu | 03/11/2004 | BIG EAST Tournament | Madison Square Garden | ESPN/ESPN2 | TBA |
| Fri | 03/12/2004 | BIG EAST Tournament | Madison Square Garden | ESPN/ESPN2 | TBA |
